Evaluate the cognitive approach

Evaluate the cognitive approach

Evaluating the Cognitive Approach

Positives of the Approach

  • The Cognitive Approach provides useful insights into mental processes such as thinking, memory, language and decision making. This allows us to better understand how these processes contribute to human behaviour.

  • It attempts to explain behaviour through scientific and objective methods, such as lab experiments and brain scans, thereby increasing the reliability and validity of its findings.

  • The approach has significant practical applications, especially in areas of cognitive and mental health therapies. For instance, it has been instrumental in the development of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT).

  • The concept of schemas has helped in understanding and explaining how individuals interpret, process and react to information differently.

  • The cognitive approach is continually evolving and incorporating new technologies to study brain functions. Thus, it’s a progressive approach.

Limitations of the Approach

  • Critics argue that the cognitive approach excessively relies on computer metaphors when describing cognitive processes and this can be limiting and unrealistic. Human cognition and behaviour are often much more complex and cannot be completely accounted for by mechanistic computer models.

  • Cognitive approach typically ignores or downplays the significance of biological mechanisms and environmental influences on behaviour and cognitive processes.

  • Critics also argue that the cognitive approach often neglects to consider emotional and social aspects of cognition, which are also essential in shaping human behaviour.

  • The cognitive approach may overstate the level of conscious control people have over their behaviour. It could pay more attention to unconscious processes.

Key Concepts and Theorists

  • It is important to understand how cognitive psychologists such Berglas and Jones, and language development theories from Noam Chomsky can either support or contradict the understanding of the cognitive approach.

  • Concepts such as the dual process theory and holistic theory can advance arguments for the effectiveness of cognitive processes, but they can also be used to criticise the cognitive approach for failing to provide a complete picture of human cognition.

  • Some theories such as Becker’s Cognitive Theory of Multimedia Learning suggest that different cognitive processes interact with one another in complex ways, offering more nuanced understanding of cognition than the traditional views proposed by the cognitive approach.

  • Ultimately, evaluation of cognitive approach will largely depend on the specific methods, concepts, and theories being applied, as well as the particular context or behavioural phenomena under investigation.