An evaluation of the obstacles to German unification, 1815-50

An evaluation of the obstacles to German unification, 1815-50

Influence of the Vienna Settlement

  • The Vienna Settlement in 1815 established a balance of power in Europe which aimed to prevent any dominant force within the continent, thus posing an obstacle to German unification.
  • The German Confederation consisting of 39 states was created by the Congress of Vienna, with Austria as the leading power, again suppressing the idea of a unified Germany.

Role of Austria and Prussia

  • The rivalry between Austria and Prussia, two dominant German states, served as a significant roadblock. They both sought to extend their influence over other German states, complicating the idea of unity.
  • Austria in particular was unsupportive of unification because it would mean a reduction in its influence over the other states of the German Confederation.
  • Prussia, while more modernised and potentially more supportive of unification, was still a feudal society under the rule of a conservative king.

Lack of Nationalism

  • Absence of nationalism among the general population led to the persistence of local loyalties and a lack of push for national unification, predominantly among the German elites and middle classes.
  • Difference in language, customs, and laws among the various states made it hard for citizens to identify as one nation. The cultural diversity created a barrier to unification.

Influence of Foreign Powers

  • Other European powers such as France and Russia did not want a united Germany as its creation would upset the balance of power.
  • Fear of a powerful united Germany led to external interventions to uphold the status quo, making unification more difficult.

Economic Differences

  • Varying levels of economic development among German states made unification tricky. While states like Prussia had embraced industrialisation, others remained largely agricultural.
  • The introduction of the Prussian Customs Union (Zollverein) in 1834, although a step towards economic unity, created discontent among other German states, particularly Austria, as Prussia was the controlling power.

Reactionary Rule and Censorship

  • The German Confederation was run by conservative, autocratic rulers who resisted unification and other liberal, democratic ideas.
  • Strict censorship prevented the spread of nationalist and democratic ideas among the people.
  • Frequent suppression of revolutionary uprisings, like those in 1848, hindered the development of a unified national movement.