Types of Market Failure

Market Failure

__Market failure __occurs whenever the free market mechanism results in an inefficient allocation of resources. This means that the economic benefits of the production of goods and services are not being maximised. The market mechanism is sending inaccurate or inappropriate signals as to how resources should be used.

An inefficient allocation of resources can come about as a result of either, or both of the following:

  1. The output of goods is not productively efficient. This occurs when goods are not being produced at the lowest possible cost (given the current state of technology and knowledge). This means that the economy is operating inside its Production Possibility Frontier, so resources are being wasted_. _A topical example is the low productivity (output per worker) in the U.K., compared to some of our close competitors. Some economists blame this on the failure of businesses to invest sufficiently in training workers or buying more efficient machinery.
  2. The output of goods is not allocatively efficient. This means that the price of the good is being over-produced or under-produced. Overproduction occurs if the price is lower than the marginal cost of production. For instance, if consumers are prepared to pay £5 for an item that will cost a firm an extra £6 to produce, that item should not be produced; £1 worth of resources is being wasted. Underproduction occurs in the opposite situation; if the price is £6 and the marginal cost is £5, more units are worth producing as the benefits (measured by the price consumers are willing to pay), exceeds the cost of producing them.

Types of Market Failure, figure 1


_Externalities __refer to the costs or benefits of economic activity that affect third parties, or society as a whole rather than the producers or consumers of the good in question. _Externalities result in allocative inefficiency, and are a major cause of market failure.

For instance, a firm that disposes of hazardous waste by dumping it free of charge in a river, imposes costs on others, for instance a fish farm downstream. These costs are not reflected in the price charged by the polluting firm to its customers, so the good is being over-produced.

Externalities generally result in a partial market failure. This means that the good in question can be provided by the market mechanism, but it is either over-produced or under-produced.

Missing Markets

A missing market __occurs when the market mechanism cannot provide at all a good or a service that is wanted. In this case there is complete market failure __(no provision at all).

The best example of this is found in the case of a __public good, __such as national defence. A public good is consumed collectively by society as a whole, rather than by individuals, and once it is provided, everyone benefits, regardless of whether they have paid towards the cost of providing it. It is not therefore possible to construct a market in which people can choose to buy a certain amount; we can’t measure individual consumption of defence, and we can’t deny its benefits to those who choose not to pay.

Information Problems

Types of Market Failure, figure 1

For a market to work efficiently, producers and consumers need accurate and complete information about the prices being charged by other firms and the quality of the goods on sale. This is often not the case. When you go shopping, how confident are you that you have bought the items at the lowest price available? Sometimes it is very difficult to discover the best price available, although online shopping makes this much easier.

A more intractable information problem is to do with quality of goods rather than price. Consumers are often at a disadvantage compared to producers. In private medicine for instance, it may be very easy for doctors to prescribe expensive treatment which is either not needed at all, or no more effective than cheaper alternatives. Economists call this the problem of asymmetric information, where one party to the transaction (usually the seller) has much better knowledge of the product than the other party.

As a result of information problems, some goods (expensive and shoddy) may be produced instead of cheaper, better alternatives. The former are being over-produced and the latter under-produced.