Plot: Visit to Dr Stead

Plot: Visit to Dr Stead

Overview of Plot Point

  • In The Trick is to Keep Breathing, Joy’s visits to Dr Stead, her psychiatrist, form a prominent subplot.
  • These scenes are crucial for illustrating Joy’s deteriorating mental health and the inadequate mental health care system.
  • Dr Stead’s attitude towards Joy and his inability to fully understand her distress help highlight the isolation and misunderstanding individuals with mental health issues often face.

Key Interactions

  • Joy’s dialogue with Dr Stead displays her frustration and hopelessness as he appears dismissive and offers little empathy towards her struggles.
  • The contrast between Dr Stead’s professional exterior and Joy’s internal suffering draws attention to the gap between lived experiences of mental health patients and their treatment.
  • Dr. Stead’s prescription of medication without adequate emotional support illustrates the tendency to treat only symptoms, not the underlying emotional distress.

Significance of the Scene

  • The visits to Dr Stead show the ineffectiveness and insensitivity of the mental health care system, an important criticism Galloway includes in the novel.
  • These scenes show Joy’s increasing desperation and frustration, amplifying the novel’s exploration of the isolation associated with mental health struggles.
  • Dr. Stead’s inability to truly help Joy supports the novel’s depiction of mental illness as an often misunderstood and mishandled condition.

Key Themes

  • Isolation: Joy’s ineffective communications with Dr Stead emphasise her feelings of alienation and miscomprehension.
  • Medicalisation of Mental Illness: Dr Stead’s reliance on medication rather than emotional understanding criticises the medical approach to mental health.
  • Despair: Joy’s fruitless visits to Dr Stead underline her escalating despair and diminishing hope for recovery.

Relevant Quotes

  • “He gives me the prescription. It is always the same.” - This line emphasises Dr Stead’s clinical approach and invokes a sense of monotony, which mirrors Joy’s bleak reality.
  • “He doesn’t listen…he doesn’t want to know.” - Joy’s internal thoughts during her visits to Dr Stead reveal her feelings of being unheard and misunderstood.
  • “I am tired of this. Tired of me.” - This line captures Joy’s mental exhaustion and despair at the lack of effective help.