Theme: Good versus Evil

Theme: Good versus Evil

Overview: Good versus Evil

  • “The Cone Gatherers” by Robin Jenkins explores the universal theme of Good versus Evil making the novel an allegorical tale.
  • The two main characters, Neil and Calum, often represent the forces of good, while the antagonist, Duror, represents the evil force.

The Cone Gatherers: Symbol of Good

  • Neil and Calum, the cone gatherers, are depicted as innocent and kind-hearted characters.
  • Calum, an innocent hunchback, treats all living creatures with compassion, demonstrating the purity of heart.
  • Neil, protective of his brother, embodies the virtue of loyalty and serves as a counterpoint to the evil characters.

Duror: Embodiment of Evil

  • Duror, the gamekeeper, symbolises evil and is portrayed as having a bitter, hateful nature.
  • His malice towards the cone gatherers crosses boundaries of reason; his aim is to destroy their happiness.
  • Duror’s extreme hatred of Calum roots from his own dissatisfaction with his life, further intensifying the evil aspect of his character.

Internal Struggle between Good and Evil

  • The book explores the internal struggle between good and evil within each character.
  • Duror’s struggle with his feelings for the cone gatherers portrays an inner conflict of Good against Evil.
  • By the end, Duror’s evil prevails leading to tragic consequences, suggesting that evil had the upper hand.

External Competition of Good and Evil

  • The forest, where most of the events occur, serves as a battleground for the competition of good and evil.
  • Despite being victims of societal prejudices, Neil and Calum maintain their good nature, standing up against the evil embodied by Duror.
  • The tragic ending signifies a temporary victory for evil, but Jenkins leaves the question of ultimate victory open-ended.

Conclusion

  • The theme of Good versus Evil in “The Cone Gatherers” is a stark reminder of the moral choices individuals must make.
  • Although the novel ends tragically, it doesn’t negate the power of goodness and kindness displayed by the cone gatherers.
  • The continuous struggle and balance between good and evil provide the novel with a rich depth and a compelling storyline.